Buried In A Paupers Grave In Manahawkin

Dated: December 30 2016

Views: 1279

There are graves in the cemetery at the Baptist Church in Manahawkin that hold an unknown number of dead, without names, buried in a pauper’s fashion. They washed ashore near Beach Haven on April 16, 1854 when the emigrant ship Powhattan, filled with Germans coming to the United States, broke apart on the shoals.


Built in 1836-1837 in Baltimore, Maryland with W. Graham listed as the owner and D. Griffith as the Captain, the Powhattan was a transport ship of 598 tons gross. The packet ship Powhattan made trips across the Atlantic from England, France, and the Netherlands to the ports of Baltimore and New York.


Image title

                                                                                       Powhattan

About the first of March 1854, the Powhattan left Le Havre, France bound for New York City with approximately 200 German emigrants and under the command of Captain James Meyers with a crew of 25. At the end of its journey, the Powhattan encountered a hurricane strength winter storm, one of the worst in recorded history, that drove it ashore on April 15, 1854 on the Barnegat Shoals off the present day Surf City. The weather was so bad that a lifesaving station six miles away was unable to send help.


By the morning of the 16th, a small crowd had gathered on shore watching the tragedy unfold. In late afternoon, the bow of the Powhattan breached, and the ship broke in two. Bodies began to wash ashore, some of the victims as far south as Atlantic City. In Beach Haven, the local wreckmaster, Edward Jennings, who managed the local hotel known as the Mansion of Health, began the task of assembling the bodies and accounting for the valuables.


Image title

                                                                               Mansion of Health

When the storm subsided and the local coroner arrived, he noted that none of the bodies possessed any money or valuables. This was considered highly unusual because immigrants brought their lifesavings with them normally held in money belts to start a new life in the new world. Suspicion fell on Jennings, but he upheld his innocence.


Fifty-four victims were buried in a mass grave at Smithville Methodist Church; forty-five were buried in Absecon; and approximately 140 were buried in the Baptist Cemetery in Manahawkin. Several months later, another storm exposed a trove of cut open and empty money belts by a cedar tree stump. Jennings fled Ocean County to avoid prosecution and died several years later in a bar-room brawl in San Francisco.


Image title

                                                                       Monument in Manahawkin

The wreck of the Powhattan is one of the worst New Jersey shipwrecks in terms of loss of life, and is the basis for untold number of ghost stories. The Mansion of Health stayed open for another year before stories of apparitions forced its closure. Vacant, it burned in 1874. In 1904, the State of New Jersey erected a monument in the Manahawkin cemetery remembering the victims of the Powhattan tragedy.


From your “Running Realtor” Andrew Gonzales…

Blog author image

Andrew Gonzales

As a lifelong resident of Ocean County, New Jersey, Andrew Gonzales brings exceptional insight into local market trends, and full knowledge of ordinances, insurance requirements, and FEMA standards. A....

Latest Blog Posts

Classic Eggnog For The Holiday Season

 A drink that started back in the 13th century, Eggnog has evolved into a delicious treat  enjoyed around the world during the holidays.  Enjoy this simple recipe! 

Read More

New Long Beach Island Real Estate Single Family Home Listings Fall 2021

 New Long Beach Island Real Estate Single Family Home Listings Fall 2021Long Beach Island Real EstateThe Long Beach Island real estate sales market has seen a tremendous amount of

Read More

Long Beach Island Real Estate Weekly Sales Update LBI Real Estate Weekly Sales 1121202111282021

 Long Beach Island Real Estate Weekly Sales Update LBI Real Estate Weekly Sales 11/21/2021-11/28/2021Long Beach Island Real EstateLBI Real Estate Weekly Sales Update 11/21/2021-11/28/2021:

Read More

Four Great Home Features That Buyers Are Craving

(1)  HOME OFFICE:  Thanks to today's technology, more workers stayed home to do their jobs last year.  Over 70% of the workforce say they want to continue working from their

Read More